Independent 3PL selection

Choosethe3PLyouroperationactuallyneeds.

3PL selection is our core offering. We build the shortlist, take the introductory calls, and ask the operational questions. We compare the full cost, negotiate with the finalists, and help manage the move and the first months of the relationship.

Freak Athlete used this process across three regions. Across our client work, 85% of messages are answered within the hour.

A search built around your operation
10–15
Providers typically evaluated

Sourced for your products, channels, and order profile.

2–3
Finalist conversations

Comparable proposals. Specific questions. Your team involved.

01
Partner to move forward with

Negotiated terms, a transition plan, and support after signing.

One operation. Different promises.

DTC
Amazon
Retail
Wholesale
Key accounts
Customization

Omnichannel brands do not need a warehouse that can ship a box. They need a partner that can keep different inventory rules, integrations, workflows, and working at the same time.

Watch the process

How I actually
find a good 3PL.

I've run dozens of 3PL searches and helped build a global fulfillment network. This is what I look for, what I ask, and how I compare the proposals.

KEYAN BAZARGAN · FOUNDER, IRON MARGIN
Keyan comparing carrier cost and 3PL markup for the same shipment10:01
00:39Build the shortlist
03:32Understand the shipping quote
07:16Negotiate the proposal
How to Actually Find a Good 3PL

How we run your search

From the first brief
to the first months with your 3PL.

We do the sourcing, evaluation, and negotiation. Your team joins the finalist calls and makes the decision. We stay involved through the move and the early relationship.

01

Define the work

Build the brief from your orders, channels, storage, systems, and growth plans. Show the packout so providers can quote the actual work.

02

Build a qualified shortlist

Typically evaluate 10–15 qualified providers against the brief. Ask who they already fulfill for, what they ship, and where your brand fits in their customer mix.

03

Compare the same 90 days

Give each bidder the same shipping file. Compare carrier costs, markup, surcharges, pick and pack, storage, minimums, and account fees.

04

Negotiate with specifics

Tell each provider where the proposal needs to improve. Explore carrier options, markup, and process changes that reduce the work and the price.

05

Choose, move, and stabilize

Bring your team into 2–3 finalist calls. Review contract terms, coordinate the transition, check the first invoices, and set up communication for the first two months.

What the quote leaves out

A lower markup
can still cost more.

The 3PL's carrier rates matter as much as its markup. Then come fuel, dimensional weight, and accessorials. We ask every bidder to price the same 90 days of orders so you can compare the full bill.

3PL A20% markup
Carrier cost
$5.00
3PL markup
$1.00
You pay
$6.00
3PL B10% markup
Carrier cost
$6.00
3PL markup
$0.60
You pay
$6.60

Illustrative pricing for the same shipment and included charges. Actual quotes must also account for service, surcharges, and operating fit.

What we compare

Check how the operation will work.

We ask providers to explain the workflows your team will rely on. A feature list is useful; a clear answer to a real scenario is more useful.

Ask what happens when an order is canceled in Shopify, when stock is short, or when a shipment goes wrong. We compare the answers, the systems, and the people who will do the work.

Operational fit

Products, packaging, kitting, B2B routing, returns, customization, geography, and peak capacity.

WMS, ERP and integrations

The WMS they run, Shopify and marketplace connections, ERP migration, EDI, and whether the API is genuinely open.

Data and accountability

Order-level data access, billing detail, inventory accuracy, SLA measurement, exception reporting, and claims recovery.

Communication

Who answers, where the work happens, escalation paths, response standards, and access to someone near the operation.

Fully loaded economics

Postage, pick and pack, storage, receiving, packaging, minimums, returns, onboarding, projects, and account fees.

Commercial terms

Pricing leverage, renewal mechanics, service commitments, liability, implementation obligations, and a clean exit if the fit changes.

Built from real searches

From a large field to a partner that can grow with you.

We have run this process for consumer brands including Freak Athlete, turning broad provider markets into structured finalist decisions and supporting the work after the selection.

After the contract is signed

A good partner still needs a clear handoff.

Inventory transfer. Communication channels. Order workflows. First-invoice checks. We stay involved while the new relationship gets established.

What to expect

Questions before a 3PL search

What do you handle, and when does my team get involved?

We build the brief, source qualified providers, take the initial calls, compare proposals, and negotiate. Your team joins the two or three finalist conversations and makes the decision. We then support contract review, inventory transfer, and the first months of the relationship.

Do you only recommend 3PLs you already know?

No. We source against your actual requirements, typically starting with 10 to 15 qualified providers. Existing relationships and introductions can be part of the list, but each provider needs to fit your products, channels, geography, systems, and order profile.

How do you compare proposals with different rate cards?

We ask each bidder to price the same 90 days of shipping data, then compare shipping, fuel, accessorials, pick and pack, storage, receiving, minimums, and other fees. A lower markup or pick fee does not necessarily produce a lower total bill.

Does the engagement end when we choose a 3PL?

No. We help review terms, coordinate the move, establish communication and order workflows, and check the first invoices. The first two months with a new partner matter: a capable 3PL still needs a clear handoff and a working relationship with your team. The scope and timeline are agreed for your operation.

What if we can fix the relationship with our current 3PL?

That can be the right outcome. We look at the operational issues, the costs, and what the incumbent can realistically improve before recommending a move. A new warehouse is useful when it solves the problem; switching is not the goal by itself.

Ready when the fit matters

Bring us the operation you have and the one you are building.

We will tell you whether to fix the incumbent, negotiate the current deal, or run the market.